Showing posts with label Azpilicueta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Azpilicueta. Show all posts

Monday, June 23, 2014

Luke Shaw for £27m? No thanks, we got Flanagan

Rumor has it Luke Shaw is headed to Man U for £27m.  That's a preposterous amount for a player who will definitely not become the next Gareth Bale.  In fact, he'll be lucky if he can become the next Leighton Baines or Aleksandar Kolarov.  Here's a look at stats from last season for Shaw, Flanagan, and a few other top left backs:

ShawFlanaganBainesAzpilicuetaKolarov
age19*21292428
app(subs)35233226(3)21(9)
mins29901890283823251977
goals01501
assist11407
chances3313481234
npgp9000.050.0600.05
gcp900.030.10.2900.36
ccp900.990.621.50.471.6
pass%7983.785.880.681.2
bp%41.642.641.437.143.5
sacc%41.742.923.84024.5
shot%014.323.801.9
tp902.23.833.82.3
tack %58.745.760.352.956.2
intp901.11.91.11.91.4
clrp903.73.62.55.32.8
dribpp900.71.90.61.10.8
bsp900.10.20.20.30.1
adwp901.81.40.41.31.7
adwon%56.546.841.258.671.7
TTI9011.69.29.110.110.9
* Shaw will turn 19 next month.

Compared to Flanagan, Shaw is the better chance creator, more efficient tackler, and significantly superior in the air, but our number 38 has a higher pass rate, nearly doubles his counterpart's tackles and clearances, and holds onto the ball better.  If Southampton were to offer Shaw for Flanagan, Rodgers would be an idiot not to take them up on it, but that would never happen.  It's not that Shaw is that much better than our 'Red Cafu' and the distance between their productivity may never be much, but Shaw has more potential.

Comparing Shaw to the others above, he is probably most similar to Kolarov.  The Serbian is a great attacking left back, but is not an exceptional defender like Azpilicueta.  Would I have paid £27m for Kolarov at (soon-to-be) 19, if I had known then what I do now? Probably, but with Shaw there's no such luxury.  It's still a crap shoot with all that can happen in his young career.

The one thing that will improve at a bigger club is the quality of his teammates.  No offense to Southampton, but Adam Lallana is no Steven Gerrard and Rickie Lambert is not even a poor man's Rooney.  Having players around him who are quicker and more talented overall should improve his numbers.  It certainly helps Kolarov.

If I've said it once, I've said 'til your eyes bleed, if we are going to splash that kind of cash for a left back or really any player, it should be Ricardo Rodriguez. He is the real deal and can provide coverage on the wing as well.  Shaw is just not worth the risk when we have fully capable coverage in Flanagan.

Popular Posts