No matter how it plays out though, £17.6m to sign Balotelli is a much better deal than acquiring Falcao on a year-long loan for £6.7m plus £10m salary and an option to buy him at the end of the season for an additional £40m. Super Mario is basically a younger, faster, stronger, and more skilled verison of Falcao. If anyone complains, like myself, that all Ballotelli can do is score goals, well, Falcao can only score less. Plus the Italian can physically impose himself on the opposition and worry their defence to no end, creating space for teammates. I don't see the 177cm (5'10"), 72kg (160lb) Colombian with no Premier League experience having much presence, wait until they play Stoke.
Their career club league stats are quite comparable:
npg90 | ap90 | gc90 | cc90 | ccv | pass% | sacc% | shot% | sdr90 | tti90 | gopd | |
Balotelli | 0.47 | 0.14 | 0.77 | 1.33 | 0.1 | 0.757 | 0.382 | 0.121 | 2.14 | 14.6 | -0.46 |
Falcao | 0.57 | 0.08 | 0.75 | 0.90 | 0.05 | 0.797 | 0.492 | 0.305 | 0.79 | 11.21 | 0.06 |
First things first, Falcao is four-and-a-half years older than Super Mario. Which means he's probably at his peak and won't improve much more, not to mention he'll have to make the adjustments for the English game. Quick, name a 28-year-old South American and/or La Liga player who came to the Premier League and made a significant impact? Don't even try to say Valencia, he's been in the league for eight years now. The closest is probably Coloccini, but he was 26 when he signed with Newcastle and he's a defender. Maybe Falcao will make history, but I doubt it.
Mario is a better team player and that says mountains, since we all know what kind of a 'team player' he is. The thing is, Balotelli has the ability to be a great asset to the club as a whole, while I don't think Falcao has the capacity to do so, because if he did, he would have already done so with Porto or Atletico or Monaco. He has never been a significant 'defending forward' and forget about setting up others on goal. When Balotelli cares and tries, which honestly, this is his last chance to do so before he becomes a true pariah, he is eons better than his Colombian counterpart.
In the end, it won't matter though. If Falcao scores goals and does nothing else, even have the worst efficiency in the league, the Mangoloids won't care. I honestly think the EPL is too physical for him and can see an injury-riddled season where he gets sent packing back to Monaco in the end.
(Oh and just a quick point because I can see it coming, 16 of Falcao's last 63 league goals since joining La Liga have been penalties compared to 15 of 55 for Balotelli, so save that rubbish for your pub trash bin banter.)